PHI 413 Topic 1 Discussion Question 2

PHI 413 Topic 1 Discussion Question 2

This class is the most thought-provoking class I can ever remember taking. I had to really dig deep after reading the first chapter to consider my worldview. I have never been asked to consider my worldview, which consists of my ideas of what reality is and how I interpret these experiences of our world according to my worldview (Bogue & Hogan, 2020). It was not until after I read this first chapter that I started to really understand my own worldview and realized that it has evolved over the years and that each person has their own worldview which may be the reason for how they address certain moral or ethical issues in life and in their professional practice in health care.

Although my worldview has evolved, what I do and find meaningful in my life still follows the same moral and ethical compass but realize it has become simplified. At first, I did not think my worldview was religious as I am a Catholic who does not attend Catholic mass any longer. I still consider myself a Catholic and have a strong belief in God and try to live a life of virtue with the help and grace of God. My personal character, morals, values, and conduct have remained pretty much the same all my life and are also incorporated into my professional nursing conduct and practice when caring for my patients and interacting with my coworkers. I believe that I have a good foundation which helps me to make the best ethical decisions in my personal and professional life. I think now that I have really considered what my worldview is, it is important that I am accountable to myself to always bring my very best in my personal and professional practice. These last two years of Covid has been trying times for everyone. It is important that despite how tired, unappreciated or disrespected we feel, we must dig deep if necessary so we can continue to remain kind, compassionate and respectful, to our friends, family, coworkers, patients and strangers.

Due to everyone having their own worldview, there are many different views on disease and healing. Some have a scientific or religious approach whereas some may be a mix of both. I think I fall into the category of viewing disease and healing due to my belief in God and what I have learned from science. The story about the 26-week infant with the brain lesion is similar to situations I have experienced in my nursing practice. In this situation I would ask the patient what their faith was and see if they wanted to consult in person with a priest or Chaplin. To withdraw treatment or cause the death of this infant based on what may be this infants prognosis in a few years is wrong in my belief. We do not know what the possible future medical advancements are and that could be very beneficial to this infant to improve their quality of life. This infants life needs to have many people collaborate to do what is best for this child. I do not believe a parent should make this kind of decision based on the infants doctor’s recommendation without consulting a priest and another specialist. I have had to be with a baby who was born too early or had congenital health problems that were not compatible with life. One time stands out was when the parents did not want to hold their infant child as it took its last breaths. The nurses were told take the baby out of the patients room at their request and put the baby in the nursery. The doctors were surprised the 20-week baby was born alive and continues to have a heartbeat for almost half an hour. It was heartbreaking. I provided comfort care for this baby and cried when the heartbeat stopped. I tried to keep my emotional wall up but it was just too sad, I could not keep it together. I did not judge this infant parents for not wanting to hold and comfort their baby while it died. I offered my patient compassion and condolences as I continued providing her with care. I thought to myself, I am not this women and I am not living her life so I cannot be prejudiced against her and judge her related to the bad decisions she made during this pregnancy or how she acted when her child was born and died. When I was a younger nurse, I may not have been as understanding and compassionate and may have judged her for the bad decisions she made such as taking illicit drugs while pregant which was the leading cause for her preterm delivery and death of her child. That is one way my worldview evolved and has changed me for the better in my professional nursing practice.

References

Bogue, D.W. & Hogan, M. (2020). Foundational issues in Christian spirituality and ethics. In Practicing dignity: An introduction to Christian values & decision making in health care (1st ed.). https://lc.gcumedia.com/phi413v/practicing-dignity-an-introduction-to-christian-values-and-decision-making-in-health-care/v1.1/#/chapter/1

What aspects of the topic readings do you find the most interesting? What is your view of the analysis of disease and healing in the readings? Explain.

Re: Topic 1 DQ 2: PHI 413 Topic 1 Discussion Question 2
What aspects of the topic readings do you find the most interesting? What is your view of the analysis of disease and healing in the readings? Explain.The aspects of the topic reading that I find most interesting is the role of spirituality in healthcare. I find it interesting because nursing to me is an occupation of service or caring for the patient in every aspect, or as a whole (Puchlaski, 2001). I try to care for the person whether they are a judge, a drug addict, or anywhere in between. I do admit that sometimes it is harder to care for the patient if I feel as though they are not trying to care for themselves, but their soul matters as much as mine does to Jesus. I try to always remember this when caring for a patient. God does not make a person good or bad. Choices made by a person are what places a person in situations that they feel are out of their control sometimes. Temptation comes from Satan and he would love to see us wind up where he is by our disobedience. Satan was, after all, an angel at one time. (choices, choices).

My view of the analysis of disease and healing in the readings is that without disease there would be no healing and that God provided us with the minds to be able to help to heal his creations. In order to be healed one must believe in a higher power and the ability of that power to heal us. A patient looks at medical personnel as the ones with the ability to heal us (not all believe in a higher power, just as all medical personnel do not believe in a higher power). As for me, I believe that God gave people in the medical profession the ability to help heal people through Him by His giving us the knowledge to do so (if not physically then through acceptance of what is to come). I was diagnosed with stage III lymphoma 2 years ago and am still undergoing treatment. I also work full time as a bedside nurse. I have been told that I am eligible for disability, but I do not believe that is all that I am on this earth for. I believe that I will fulfill my days that God has given me and that as long as I am physically able, then I will serve Him by helping others as a nurse.

References

Puchalski, C. (2001). The role of spirituality in health care. Retrieved from

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1305900/

Re: Topic 1 DQ 2
The idea of scientism is interesting and honestly, a little far-fetched to me. I am not sure that I ever heard of this concept prior to reading about it. That belief seems to be rooted in the fact that if it can’t be proven scientifically, it can’t be known. It is a philosophy that science is the only way to gain knowledge or any particular subject. Since science itself is limited and can’t provide facts about moral or ethical concerns, it is hard to imagine how this concept could gain traction (Burnett, 2018).Healing from disease can come in different forms. Sometimes it comes in the form of physical healing where the disease is cured and the body shows no signs of the disease. Other times healing comes in the form of making peace with the disease itself. When a patient is allowed to verbalize and integrate their own spiritual beliefs in the treatment plan, that can bring healing even when physical healing isn’t possible.

Burnett, T. (2018). What is Scientism? Retrieved from

Re: Topic 1 DQ 2
The article by Christina Puchalski (2001), titled ‘The role of spirituality in health care’ really was interesting. I understand we use holistic care in our nursing practices all the time and that a person’s spirituality influences a patient’s health. Though a patient might be of a certain religion, their belief in spirituality is multifaceted and different from one another (Puchalski, 2001). The fact that we must set our own biases aside regarding a patient’s beliefs or spirituality is something I strongly believe in. The article also states to have a chaplain within the interdisciplinary team for healing a patient. But sometimes a health professional gets caught in the process and the patient ask for prayer which can be difficult for an individual. I find it difficult at times as it can be uncomfortable. But I have noticed through years of experience and being exposed to many beliefs, I have come to understand that it is important to put their needs and beliefs in the forefront as that is what they require to heal.References

Puchalski C. M. (2001). The role of spirituality in health care. Proceedings (Baylor University. Medical Center), 14(4), 352–357. https://doi.org/10.1080/08998280.2001.11927788

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *