NU 665 WEEK 7 DISCUSSION POST 1: EVALUATING A TREATMENT PLAN FOR A PATIENT WITH POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER (PTSD)
NU 665 WEEK 7 DISCUSSION POST 1: EVALUATING A TREATMENT PLAN FOR A PATIENT WITH POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER (PTSD)
Value: 100 points
Due: Create your initial post by Day 3 and reply to at least two of your peers by Day 7.
Grading Category: Discussions
Note: In this type of discussion, you will not see the responses of your classmates until after you have posted your own response to the following prompt.
This is an exercise intended to help you identify the benefits and shortcomings of generative artificial intelligence (GAI) use in healthcare and education settings.
The following prompt was entered into ChatGPT™: “Create a PMHNP treatment plan for a 49-year-old female Latinx patient with a diagnosis of PTSD and alcohol use disorder”.
Initial Post
Critique the Treatment Plan for PTSD developed by ChatGPT™ by creating a video up to five minutes long answering any two of the following prompts.
- Please provide a brief rationale for each test in the diagnostic tools section. Are they appropriate?
- Establishing treatment goals: Are the short-term and long-term goals appropriate?
- Brief reflection: do you set clear treatment goals in clinical?
- Please describe the treatment plan you would choose for this patient.
- Pharmacologic option for PTSD
- Pharmacologic option for alcohol use disorder
- Type of therapy and why
- Please briefly describe the strengths and shortcomings of
- The non-pharmacologic treatment options for this patient
- The patient education section
- The follow up plan
- Addressing of the patient’s cultural needs
You will need to cite at least two research-based resources for this discussion.
To create your video, follow the instructions for Zoom Tutorial and create an unlisted YouTube video. The following tools can be used to create your video: Zoom or your personal preference.
You will need to submit the YouTube video URL for this discussion. The best way to do this is to copy and paste the hyperlink URL for the YouTube video into a Word document. Your faculty will access your video via the link. Do not upload a video file (mp4).
Replies
Reply to at least two of your peers. In each of your reply posts, write a maximum of two paragraphs (with two to three sentences each). Describe what you would do differently than your peer. Also explain something new you learned from your peer’s post. These paragraphs should synthesize one to two pieces of research.
Please make certain that your initial and reply posts are in APA format. Please refer to the Grading Rubric for details on how this activity will be graded.
The described expectations meet the passing level of 80%. You are directed to review the Discussion Grading Rubric for criteria which exceed expectations.
Introduction
For this discussion, you will review and critique a ChatGPT-generated treatment plan developed for a 49-year-old Latinx female diagnosed with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and Alcohol Use Disorder (AUD). The purpose of this exercise is to critically evaluate the strengths and limitations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GAI) in formulating psychiatric treatment plans, particularly in the context of cultural sensitivity, diagnostic accuracy, and clinical applicability. As artificial intelligence tools become increasingly integrated into healthcare and education, it is essential for psychiatric-mental health nurse practitioners (PMHNPs) to understand both their potential and their shortcomings in clinical decision-making.
PTSD and AUD often coexist, creating complex challenges for treatment planning, adherence, and recovery. This case invites reflection on how GAI models conceptualize trauma-informed care, pharmacologic management, and evidence-based psychotherapy. It also encourages a closer look at whether AI-generated plans appropriately address cultural identity, language considerations, and the patient’s lived experiences, all of which are vital components of holistic and ethical mental health care.
In this discussion, I will focus on two key areas: (1) evaluating the appropriateness and rationale of the diagnostic tools used in the AI-generated treatment plan, and (2) examining the strengths and weaknesses of the non-pharmacologic and patient education components. The goal is to determine how well ChatGPT aligns with current clinical practice guidelines and to identify areas where human clinical judgment, empathy, and cultural competence remain irreplaceable.
By analyzing this AI-generated treatment plan through a professional nursing lens, this discussion aims to highlight how PMHNPs can responsibly integrate GAI tools into practice—leveraging their efficiency while maintaining critical thinking, cultural sensitivity, and evidence-based care.


Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!