Discussion 2.1: Health Program Planning

Discussion 2.1: Health Program Planning

Discussion Guidelines

Initial Post

  • Access the .
  • Listen to a podcast of your choice from the “A Cup of Health with CDC”.
  • Answer the following questions based on developing, implementing, and evaluating a program aimed at improving the health of the targeted population from the podcast.
    • Provide the title and a brief overview of the podcast.
    • Which program planning model would you choose to guide this health planning project and why?
    • What other data might you want to collect before starting?
    • Based on the data, choose one of the risk factors and discuss a possible intervention.
    • How would you evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention/program?

Response Post(s)

Respond to at least two classmates.

Submission

Post your initial and follow up responses and review full grading criteria on the page.

The podcast I have chosen to review is “Diabetes: What’s Your Type?” in the series A Cup of Health with CDC. This podcast goes through how “Diabetes is a common chronic disease and the seventh leading cause of death in the U.S.” (Dooling, p. 1). It talks through a brief overview of the two types of diabetes and the prevalence in our society, as well as signs and symptoms and the risks if it’s not managed. They also mention ways to decrease our chances of getting type 2 diabetes through the use of modifiable risks.

After reading about the two main models that help guide the implementation of program planning, I would use the logic model to help guide my practice. According to Savage, “a logic model approach to program planning can result in a plan that is clear to implement and evaluate; is based on theoretical knowledge; and includes a clear understanding of resources, time and expected outcomes” (p. 111). I believe this program planning model would guide a health planning project because of the emphasis on resources. I feel as though the populations with the most need for education and resources don’t have the access to acquire what is necessary.

Other data necessary to collect prior to beginning this program planning would involve gathering information regarding the demographics of the community, literacy levels/ education requirements/ learning needs of the community, as well as income and resource availability. Based on the current data provided one of the risk factors is inappropriate management of diabetes which leads to damage of the vascular system and nerves. In all honesty, a possible intervention is health education for adolescents. Health literacy and health education need to be educated to adolescents while still in the school system, I believe that the one semester of health education needs to be more inclusive than just the physical aspects of the human body and involve chronic diseases and their progression if not prevented or managed.

The effectiveness of the intervention/ program would involve the use of summative evaluation. While there is not quite a way to assess the understanding throughout the longevity of the lives of the adolescents and young adults while they are being educated maybe there is a way we could study and follow up with them in 10-20years after their education to see which of them developed diabetes/ complications or if they didn’t develop and if their lifestyle habits were changed. This would allow for “an assessment of the outcome and impact of the benefits the selected population has received by participating in the program” (Savage, 2020, p. 124). Though this is a very large commitment and involves a lot of data progression throughout the years it is an option that might help us better understand what happens when people are presented with appropriate information/ education while at an impressionable age.

References

Discussion 2.1 Health Program Planning

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2018, March 29). Public Health Media Library.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Retrieved October 20, 2021, from

https://tools.cdc.gov/medialibrary/index.aspx#/media/id/379468.

Savage, C. L. (2020). Public/Community Health and Nursing Practice: Caring for populations

(2nd ed.). F.A. Davis Company.

  • Provide the title and a brief overview of the podcast.      I chose to listen to Early Weight Watching on the CDC podcast. This podcast was originally posted 2.15.2018 and talks about the concern of increased weight among children. It was stated that children being overweight has tripled since the 1970s and they are experiencing obesity more than any other generation has. In 2015-16 13 million children ages 2-19 or 18.9% of the population were overweight. The podcast went to discuss the immediate health concerns with being overweight such as low self-esteem, hypertension, depression and diabetes. The other concern is the once a child is overweight, the odds of being overweight as an adult continues to be high. As adults then the concerns include premature death, cancer, hypertension, diabetes and obesity. Parents and schools can find resources through the CDC and American Pediatric Association to learn more about balancing foods, increasing activity, limiting sugar based foods and drinks and processed foods as well. Parents can also visit www.healthychildren.org for more information too (CDC, 2018).
  • Which program planning model would you choose to guide this health planning project and why?      For this situation I feel I would use the Logic Model. This is a model that is used by many program planners and is clear to implement and evaluate. It is also a good way to organize ideas and provide understanding as to the why’s and how’s of the program also.  The other beneficial point to the logic model is that once the project is complete, planners will be able to see the progress and how it is related to the objectives from the beginning which is an important piece of evaluation success or otherwise (Savage, 2020).  I believe this model provides it offers the ability to be clear and concise in its project objectives and can be evaluated effectively. The logic model is something that could be used in evaluating families and children for the prevalence of obesity and daily activities.
  • What other data might you want to collect before starting?      Other date I might want to find out before starting this type of project planning would include things such as: how many children, 18 years old and younger are in the community; is there access to nutritional food within the community; how many fast food restaurants are accessible; what types of meals are served in school; how many parents both work possibly limiting homemade meals and eating together; how many children are active in sports or other daily exercise activities; how long are physical education classes at school and what does it include; does obesity or other health concerns run in family; how many children are already overweight; how much screen time do the children have on a daily basis; do the children already have any pre-existing health issues; is the community willing to participate and do they share concerns about the children; what do food portion sizes look like.
  • Based on the data, choose one of the risk factors and discuss a possible intervention.        Based on risk factors discussed, hypertension is a leading factor for further cardiovascular disease, heart attack, stroke and premature death. For some children, the treatment plan will be to modify the diet, increase physical activity and reduce weight which can significantly lessen the risk factors associated with obesity. However, for some children who may be diagnosed with hypertension or even diabetes and have not had success with a modification plan, it may be necessary to start an anti-hypertensive medication treatment to help in reducing blood pressure. Without early intervention, childhood obesity can lead to many other significant health issues and death (Wuhl, 2019). Along with this intervention of weight reduction, increased activity and medications if needed, education of family and children about weight is necessary as well. One cannot change without knowing and understanding the reasons behind the need for change and even then it can be a challenge which may lead to the need of a check in system with school nurses or other community health professionals to see how progress is being made.
  • How would you evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention/program?        To evaluate the effectiveness of the program I would look at the success rate of reduction in overall weight and any other health issues that may have resulted from weight. I would also look to see if there have been any changes in diet to a more whole food approach vs processed sugar based foods. Looking at increased activity levels, decreased screen time and family engagement in the overall change would be some other ways to monitor effectiveness. If there are changes in these areas and health among children is increasing then the program produced what it set out to do initially. Another way to evaluate effectiveness is with community surveys or check ins to monitor how well families and schools are continuing to reinforce and solidify the changes made.

References

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2018). Early Weight Watching (A Cup of Health with CDC), February 15, 2018.  Retrieved from on October 20, 2021.

Savage, C. (2020). Public/Community Health and Nursing Practice: Caring for Populations, (2nd ed.). F.A. Davis. Philadelphia, PA.

Wuhl, E. (2019). Hypertension in Childhood Obesity. Acta Pediatrica. 2019 January, 108(1); 37-43. doi: 10.1111/apa.14551.

Edited by on Oct 20, 2021 at 2:56pm
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *